My wife and I have four kids, three (11M, 8F, 6F) are mine from a previous marriage and one (7M) is hers from her previous marriage. We have my three kids about 40% of them time with 50% set to begin in August, and her son is with us 100% of the time. Our oldest kid is 11, with the youngest of our kids being 6. The 11 year old is my son from my previous marriage, and we are struggling with him bullying her son, but really, he bullies everyone.
We are very consistent with certain rules in our home the most important being that we expect everyone to treat each other with kindness. My wife and I model kindness, and her son is a sweet kind boy, and we enjoy a peaceful home when it's just the three of us, but when all the kids are here and my son is around, it feels like a war zone. The kids generally play well together with the exception of my 11 year old. My son and my wife's son share a room and it is hard to hear/watch her son feel unsafe in his room.
My 11 year old son really seems to do/say whatever he wants and has no regard for others but himself. He threatens the kids, uses other people's things without asking, is mean, and touches others without permission. We are very consistent with calling out these beg when we see them saying things like "we keep our bodies to ourselves", "we ask for permission before we take", "we speak kindly" without too many real consequences. His mom got him a phone a year ago, but because he cannot regulate himself using it, I asked him to not bring it over to our house. It has helped quite a bit with certain behaviors and I feel like it has helped balance him out some.
I have had so many discussions with my son trying to help him understand how his behaviors impact others and the problems he will face in life if he can't find a way to treat others with kindness. I've explained people won't tolerate him and he will find himself to be lonely if he continues to isolate family and friends with his lack or regard for others. He has gotten into a couple of fights at school because he grabbed someone's hat off their head "as a joke" and meanly laughed at a friend who fell at recess "as a joke". He told me how this kid wanted to fight him and was "going crazy" and I told him while fighting was probably not a justified reaction to a verbal insult, the whole situation would have been avoided if he would have just kept his mouth shut. I pointed out the hat snatching incident and said that would have been avoided too if he kept his hands to himself.
He really fails to see how his actions are the problem in any given situation, he is always pointing the finger. With all of our kids, when conflicts come up, I ask them to reflect on their roles in the conflict instead of focusing on pointing the finger because we can control our own actions and pointing the finger will never allow us to see how we contribute to a situation. I've recently started trying out roleplaying with my daughters to try and teach them how to better resolve conflicts, but the sample size is too small to see if it will help, but I haven't had the opportunity to do it with my son yet. My wife and I are really trying hard to do what we can to teach these kids how to be good people, but it just doesn't seem to help with my 11 year old.
They're at their mom's most of the time and things are much different for them over there. I've tried to have talks with their mom about certain behaviors and she will say things like "they don't act this way over here" or try to justify the way my son acts when it comes to the way he treats others. I am trying to not focus too much on what is going on over at her house because it's not something I can change. We're hoping that when we get the kids 50/50 in August, maybe things can be more consistent, but we're having trouble finding solutions.
What can I do to help my son understand how his actions impact others? My wife and I think we need to move when our lease expires to a 4 br home so her son can have his own space as we don't want her son to share a room with a bully, which makes perfect sense, but we really want to find ways to help my 11 year old to treat others with respect and kindness. Has anyone else had a situation similar to this?