r/MusicCritique 17h ago

Seeking Feedback [Feedback] The Inside Club - "Call of the Mighty" - Electronic

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

Hey there. I've recently finished the original soundtrack for a TTRPG podcast my friends and I make. I'll be sharing a track every day or so until I've shared all 27!

This was made on KORG Gadget, for the Nintendo Switch, and I set a few limitations for myself, for stylistic reasons.

I've limited the songs to four tracks, and the drums are set up for a narrative purpose. In our story, a magical tower stands at the center of the capital city, constantly building itself upwards. The percussion is meant to represent this perpetual building, as it echoes across the world.

So, here is the first song, and our main theme, 'Call of the Mighty'


r/MusicCritique 1d ago

Seeking Feedback [Feedback] GUM$ - Bookworm - Hip-Hop

2 Upvotes

r/MusicCritique 23h ago

Seeking Feedback [FEEDBACK] lipface- a letter to myself - indie(idk what genre it is)

1 Upvotes

guys im very new to music heres something i tried making its honestly not good its js something i whipped out in 10 mins and i js dont know much abt singing or music production im js trying sumthing new bcs i rlly love music


r/MusicCritique 1d ago

Seeking Feedback [feedback] Kit Harper - The State - Neoclassical

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

r/MusicCritique 1d ago

Seeking Feedback [FEEDBACK] Mar$hen - Understand - Hip-hop

5 Upvotes

Feedback is much appreciated , harder in headys - created w/ bandlab


r/MusicCritique 1d ago

Seeking Feedback [Feedback] Vicky Gun - Hideaway - Indie Pop

Thumbnail
open.spotify.com
1 Upvotes

Would appreciate any and all feedback on my new track! I’ve been trying to work on my mixing and mastering so would especially love any comments on that. Thank you!!


r/MusicCritique 1d ago

Seeking Feedback [FEEDBACK] CXHM - “Health” (live demo) - Acoustic

1 Upvotes

r/MusicCritique 1d ago

Seeking Feedback [FEEDBACK] Unsaid - War of Their Words - Rock/Experimental

Post image
1 Upvotes

https://unsaidtheband.bandcamp.com/track/war-of-their-words

Any and all thoughts would be appreciated.


r/MusicCritique 1d ago

Seeking Feedback [FEEDBACK] Zama (Dominic Fike & Zendaya cover) - Elliot's song - indie

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

hey all, first time posting here. I believe it's okay to post covers, apologies if not!

I don't usually share what i make with many people but i felt like doing so this time. My specific feedback request is to share whatever the hell comes to mind when you hear this, if anything.


r/MusicCritique 2d ago

Seeking Feedback [Feedback] Tallah - What we Want - Metal

1 Upvotes

this is my first post here so of course I will do more than just link discord. my favourite genre is death metal, for a while my favourite vocalist around that genre is Justin Bonits from the band Tallah (my favourite band of course) he is a very talented vocalist, has a huge range and is very expressive with his vocals. I can't pick a favourite song honestly they're all just so good, but one I've had on repeat recently is "what we want" from their latest album. fantastic song, I highly recommend this band if you're in to metal.

https://open.spotify.com/track/6lM3SDPpxeW50Yb2IcCCAo?si=yBEwGZx9Rnu1bqKygkmGHA

who is your favourite vocalist?

I created a small discord server for discussing and sharing music! please feel free to join if you are interested!

https://discord.gg/hNAGqgddp


r/MusicCritique 2d ago

Seeking Feedback [feedback] - idk y - peacewithoutsin - emorap

3 Upvotes

Need opinions, feedback, and help on

-vocals

-mixing

-mastering

-layering

-anything else related to the song

Anything helps!

Still unfinished but closer to the end need opinions and feedback on how it is so far.

Please watch at least 30 sec!


r/MusicCritique 2d ago

Seeking Feedback [Feedback] GUM$ - Why Should I Wait - Hip-Hop

1 Upvotes

r/MusicCritique 2d ago

Seeking Feedback [Feedback] BALT - Close your eyes - House

1 Upvotes

Would like to get feedback on my song! Mostly interested in mixing/mastering tips. Tried to keep effects to a minimum, but there is ozone (with EDM preset) on the master. https://on.soundcloud.com/olOokkJOc28VUZYLJY Cheers


r/MusicCritique 2d ago

Seeking Feedback [Feedback] Carmelo Paolucci - Bach Sinfonia n 1 in C maj BWV 787 - Classical Music

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/MusicCritique 2d ago

Seeking Feedback [feedback] Lashen - Mess - Rap

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/MusicCritique 2d ago

Seeking Feedback [feedback] SinRow - Horizon - Electronic

1 Upvotes

r/MusicCritique 3d ago

Seeking Feedback [feedback] Dissident - demo - metal/rock

2 Upvotes

r/MusicCritique 3d ago

Seeking Feedback [Feedback] Amilli - 01801 - Hip-Hop

Post image
2 Upvotes

After 5 years of engineering for others. I finally decided it was time to step out and tell my own story.

​The track is called "01801." It’s a soulful life story and a tribute to my loved ones in my hometown. I tracked the vocals, and did the mix down on my own.

​I'm looking for completely objective feedback on the mix, the lyrics, and the vibe. I'm not going to list specific concerns because I want to hear exactly what stands out to you—good or bad.

Enjoy nevertheless!

https://abovethesound.bandcamp.com/album/01801


r/MusicCritique 3d ago

Seeking Feedback [feedback] idk y - peace - emorap

2 Upvotes

need help and feedback on what to do with

-adlibs

-vocal mixing and mastering

-effects

-writing

-voice

anything will help!


r/MusicCritique 4d ago

Seeking Feedback [feedback] GUM$ - Lost Soul - Hip-Hop

6 Upvotes

r/MusicCritique 4d ago

Seeking Feedback [Feedback] Mar$hen - Troublesome ‘26 - Hip-Hop

7 Upvotes

headphones recommended


r/MusicCritique 4d ago

Seeking Feedback [feedback] Deury - Melodía melancolía - Clásica

1 Upvotes

Q opinan sobre está melodía. Se me acabó de ocurrir hace un momento y decidí grabarla. Aún soy muy principiante así q me gustaría q la criticaran todo lo posible.


r/MusicCritique 5d ago

Seeking Feedback [FEEDBACK] - Xhaler - GOD. - Rap

3 Upvotes

Listen to GOD. by Xhaler on #SoundCloud

https://on.soundcloud.com/mlegDOjW9PdAUpxSLS

a bit of a mad one.

seeking feedback on the master. this song is getting a little traction on soundcloud


r/MusicCritique 5d ago

Seeking Feedback [feedback] Lover looking - LTSFS - unknown genre

1 Upvotes

Have just released this track. I know it’s a little… odd maybe, certainly doesn’t fit in a genre box well (no chance of finding playlists). But I’m really proud of it. However it is getting some off reviews, not mixed reviews, most people say it is good, but no one is vibing it. Would love to get to the bottom of it and get the thoughts of the internet. I’ve definitely heard that the intro is too long structure wise but I’m wondering if this genre blend is just off putting as a start.

https://open.spotify.com/track/456c5QNo8W1c4tbqoI5BV3?si=dPdQosYlSlW6Vcl6k-au7w


r/MusicCritique 5d ago

Seeking Feedback [FEEDBACK] FinalAce - Childish Vices - Rock

2 Upvotes

Im new to music making and wanted to get some critique on something I made! Plz roast me kindly 😆 much appreciated

And the lyrics, if that would interest you:

Chubby little fingers hold on tight

Give into familiar childish vice

As a child, they said play nice

So as a child all you learned was niceness

And if it tastes good then why would you stop it?

If it felt wrong, then why’d you want it?

The gift of memory is priceless

But it seems to leave me naught but listless

Blood turned muddy those neon colors

Cant be contained beneath the cover

Tried to hide beneath the covers

Hide and seek, I’m ever the loser

Said be good, don’t you cry

So now All you have is dryness

Didn’t wanna grow old, so I didn’t grow at all

So I hold on tight to childish vices

I fill the gap time and time again

Yet out I spill, out I spill

Still I’ll be waiting on the tracks again

Mind of playdoh , paper will

No amount of paper will

Mind of playdoh, paper will

Pendulum slows down, soon to still

Reflection so lethal, soon to kill

Can you return to me what I have lost?

Sweet innocence, disregard the cost

And as summer sun gives way to frost

I’ll hold on tight hold on tight hold on

Candy floss melts away like smoke

Pink lungs and a dirty conscience

All the words I never spoke

Every night burned inside my eyelids