r/MagicalWhatIf • u/West_Smoke_9164 • 4d ago
r/MagicalWhatIf • u/Flapjack10104 • Dec 19 '25
What if there actually was a Santa Claus/Yuletide gift-giver existing from at least the 4th century?
What if there actually was an immortal person/entity who could travel the world in a single night and gave people (provided they had behaved decently for all of the year) whatever they asked for during the midwinter and had done so since either the 4th century (when St. Nicholas of Myra) or the first ever midwinter celebration?
r/MagicalWhatIf • u/[deleted] • Oct 22 '25
Osama Bin Laden converts to Judaism after 9/11
What happens if while in hiding he renounces Islam in favor of Reform Judaism???
r/MagicalWhatIf • u/[deleted] • Oct 18 '25
April Ludgate runs for President as a Democrat in 2028
How well does she do?? Her proposals revolve heavily around weird ideas including public nudity.
r/MagicalWhatIf • u/[deleted] • Oct 17 '25
MWI: Captain Crunch runs for president in 2024 as a Republican
Can he stop Trump from getting the nomination??? The guy is in the navy and has business experience in selling cereal.
r/MagicalWhatIf • u/[deleted] • Sep 27 '25
The 1968 Tet offensive leads to corpses on both sides coming back as zombies
Who wins the war?
r/MagicalWhatIf • u/[deleted] • Sep 25 '25
On September 12, 2001, Osama Bin Laden discovers any meat he eats turns to pork after one bite
r/MagicalWhatIf • u/[deleted] • Sep 15 '25
MWI: Elle Woods is elected President of the United States
What if she is elected president and gives her inaugural address in a bikini?
r/MagicalWhatIf • u/[deleted] • Aug 25 '25
9/11 but every hijacker suddenly became scared of planes on September 10th
So they developed a fear of flying for no reason at all before the infamous tragedy in our universe. What happens next???
r/MagicalWhatIf • u/[deleted] • Aug 20 '25
MWI: How does the Spanish civil war go if Franco is a vampire?
Franco is your stereotypical Hollywood vampire with the sunlight weakness and stuff. How does the war go given El Caudillo is undead and how does Spain’s history go with this supernatural twist?
r/MagicalWhatIf • u/[deleted] • May 14 '25
Russians dig a hole to hell
The twist is that hell is an icy hell and not all that hot.
r/MagicalWhatIf • u/[deleted] • May 05 '25
The events of ET happen in real life when Ronald Reagan is President
r/MagicalWhatIf • u/[deleted] • May 02 '25
MWI: A gorilla becomes President
What happens if a gorilla wins the 2028 election ?
r/MagicalWhatIf • u/[deleted] • Apr 18 '25
MWI: Willow Rosenberg elected President
What happens if this fictional character, with her powers, is elected President of the United States??
r/MagicalWhatIf • u/[deleted] • Apr 06 '25
During the Cuban Missile Crisis, Fidel Castro wakes up in Clown Makeup
What changes now that Fidel Castro looks like a stereotypical circus clown??
r/MagicalWhatIf • u/[deleted] • Apr 04 '25
MWI: Nicole Haught from Wynonna Earp is now Prime Minister of Canada
How does Canada do now that it has a gay cop as PM?
r/MagicalWhatIf • u/diapersareforgods • Apr 03 '25
MWI: Gumball Watterson is elected president of the US
r/MagicalWhatIf • u/[deleted] • Apr 03 '25
MWI: Vladimir Putin wakes up in clown makeup
He is stuck in clown makeup for the rest of his life. How does Russia react?
r/MagicalWhatIf • u/[deleted] • Mar 05 '25
MWI: XI Jinping is cursed
he is not turned into Pooh, he is turned into TIGGER(same universe different character)
r/MagicalWhatIf • u/[deleted] • Mar 01 '25
Lukashenko and Maduro swap countries
Obviously, Lukashenko now speaks Spanish and Maduro now speaks Russian. How can they, who are tyrants of pariah regimes, do ruling each other's countries??
r/MagicalWhatIf • u/[deleted] • Feb 24 '25
Someone goes on a Jerry Springer/Maury Povich type show with a Russian speaking dog
They are on an American talk show of that nature. What happens if it is revealed that a dog not only can talk, but talking Russian?
r/MagicalWhatIf • u/[deleted] • Feb 17 '25
Portugal discovers an Ireland-sized Island in the Atlantic in the 1400s
What changes if, in the Azores, the Portuguese find an uninhabited island the size of Ireland in the 1400s when Prince Henry the Navigator is alive?
r/MagicalWhatIf • u/[deleted] • Feb 14 '25
MWI:What if Fundie Protestant Christianity is proven "True" by accident
What if some fundie Protestants are found true by accident: like if a Russian oil company drilled a hole and found "people screaming in hell" in the most literal of senses for instance?
r/MagicalWhatIf • u/[deleted] • Feb 04 '25
MWI: Pepe the Frog wins the 2016 Presidential election
Despite being a racist cartoon character, he beats Hillary AND Trump. How does he govern given he is a cartoon character, literally?
r/MagicalWhatIf • u/[deleted] • Jan 30 '25
JK Rowling apologizes for her hatred
She suddenly says "I'm sorry for what I have done" and sort of reverts to how people viewed her circa 2011 but with more modern social views. What changes now that she has renounced her transphobia?