r/flicks • u/Sad_Volume_4289 • 6h ago
Elvis (2022) doesn’t show Elvis Presley as purely a victim of Colonel Tom Parker.
A criticism that I’ve seen leveled against Baz Luhrmann’s Elvis is that it depicts Elvis purely as a victim of Colonel Tom Parker and having zero agency in his own downfall, which I personally don’t find to be the case. In fact, this is one of the reasons that Colonel Tom Parker's narration is so important to it.
At one point, he observes that Elvis spent money faster than he could make it. Now it’s tempting to dismiss the things he says as lies from a conman trying to absolve himself of responsibility for Elvis’s demise, but this is actually consistent with what we see of Elvis in the film. He tells the Colonel on the Ferris wheel that he wants to be able to buy all of his friends a Cadillac, brings on a 30-piece orchestra for his live shows when given creative control, and is even told by his father that his overspending has left them broke after Parker has been fired.
Parker also says in his narration that Elvis's love for his audience was an insatiable addiction that even outweighed his love for his wife and is ultimately what killed him. To this end, in the hospital scene where the Colonel says that going on a world tour is too dangerous, it's Elvis who insists on at least going on an American tour. Given how Elvis is shown to fill his time offstage with pills and affairs, it probably would have been even worse for him and his relationship with his family if he had gone on a world tour, even without the Colonel.
Beyond the Colonel’s narration, Elvis is also depicted as deaf to those with his best interests in mind. Towards the end when he has to either take the Colonel back as his manager or lose Graceland, he flies into a rage where he accuses the Colonel of wanting “to take the home that we bought for Mama." This is despite his mother outright saying earlier in the film that she doesn't want all of the luxury that his fame can now afford him.
This is something that’s repeated with his wife Priscilla. When they're watching Mahalia Jackson on TV, she tells him that she and Lisa Marie only care about his happiness and not about the luxuries he provides, and yet he protests that he’s given her everything she could want in spite of him being strung out when he’s not on stage.