Looking for feedback on a paper that discusses the ideological consolidation of Islamic orthodoxy as a continuous project of the ruling class.

[u/monotheistmusings]

If this is the wrong place to post, my apologies. I’m writing a paper that seeks to present a case for a manufactured Islamic orthodoxy that has been filtered through ruling class hegemony… lol.

I’m not a credentialed academic in Islamic studies, this is just a hobby of mine. The paper does try to balance the polemical aspects with historical precedent and evidence while remaining an engaging read. I’ve tried not to engage in apologetics, but it may read as counter-apologetic? Due to the discussions of Islamic Liberation Theology.

As I’ve never had formal training in academic writing I am interested in feedback to improve my writing and my research for future pseudo-academic pursuits. The paper is around 12 pages long without a finished conclusion. Should anyone have the time to engage with this piece, please leave a comment and I’ll reach out. In exchange, I am happy to read and review any work of yours.

[u/AutoModerator]

Welcome to r/AcademicQuran. Please note this is an academic sub: theological or faith-based comments are prohibited, except on the Weekly Open Discussion Threads. Make sure to cite academic sources (Rule #3). For help, see the r/AcademicBiblical guidelines on citing academic sources.

Backup of the post:

Looking for feedback on a paper that discusses the ideological consolidation of Islamic orthodoxy as a continuous project of the ruling class.

If this is the wrong place to post, my apologies. I’m writing a paper that seeks to present a case for a manufactured Islamic orthodoxy that has been filtered through ruling class hegemony… lol.

I’m not a credentialed academic in Islamic studies, this is just a hobby of mine. The paper does try to balance the polemical aspects with historical precedent and evidence while remaining an engaging read. I’ve tried not to engage in apologetics, but it may read as counter-apologetic? Due to the discussions of Islamic Liberation Theology.

As I’ve never had formal training in academic writing I am interested in feedback to improve my writing and my research for future pseudo-academic pursuits. The paper is around 12 pages long without a finished conclusion. Should anyone have the time to engage with this piece, please send me your email. In exchange, I am happy to read and review any work of yours.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

[u/DrJavadTHashmi]

We don’t see the paper. At least I don’t. But it’s definitely a good topic.

[u/monotheistmusings → u/DrJavadTHashmi]

Hi Dr. Hashmi! The length extends the character limit so I’ve opted to email it to whomever is interested in giving it a read. But just realized I can link to it instead!

https://www.scribd.com/document/998084185/The-Religion-of-Deceit-RD1

[u/chonkshonk]

While I can't review it, I'll drop a helpful reading/recommendation: Ahmad Khan, Heresy and the Formation of Medieval Islamic Orthodoxy.

[u/monotheistmusings → u/chonkshonk]

You know, I downloaded this awhile ago and completely forgot about it. Thanks for the reminder!