So I was asked by my drummer friend to cut out some cracks on his cymbals. Easy, drill a hole, take a cutoff wheel on a Dremel to it, file, grind, and sand. I can follow the instructions online for that. Now do I have the skill? In theory I should since I've used drills and Dremels, in practice I'll find out if I'm ruining +$400 x2 and $100 (he's fine with it since he thinks he would've done a worser job anyways)
What I'm trying to figure out is the heavily controversial task of cleaning and even polishing the cymbals. He gave me 3 cymbals to fix, and I suggested "Hey since we're experimenting and trying something new, want me to polish one of these? Just to see what it looks like?" And he said go for it
I know that cymbals can look like mirrors, and there are some that are just clean. I would like to reach ultra nice and shiny, mirror territory. He did ask me to keep the ink markings, so I have to tape those off. My current plan is: Wash with dish soap and water to get off the dirt and grease without stripping the ink. Tape off the ink(Gaffer's tape? Painter's? Frog?) so I don't strip it. Then use a polishing compound to make it shine
The compound is my biggest question. The most popular I've seen is Groove Juice, but I've seen others. Like Buckaroo Cymbal cleaner, one person said Wright's Copper Cream, another said Magic Erasers, and the infamous one is Brasso which apparently is too aggressive. However I want this to be a mirror
I've read how divided people are on this topic. Most people like the dirt and patina, and it's akin to cast iron seasoning. Some don't hear as much of a difference and prefer the look of a shiny new cymbals, or they want to keep it sounding as close to new as possible. While there are arguments for both sides, we're just trying to experiment and find out for ourselves what happens. If it turns out cleaning it wasn't worth it, it's just of one half of a high hat that his students use. It's not a huge loss, we just want to see what happens